Painting vs. Replacing Kitchen Cabinets: How to Decide
Cabinet Painting

Painting vs. Replacing Kitchen Cabinets: How to Decide

·Hamilton Painting Company

New kitchen cabinets are one of the biggest costs in a kitchen renovation. If your current cabinets are structurally sound and the layout still works, painting them can give you a dramatically different kitchen in a fraction of the time and cost. Here is how to decide.

Signs Your Cabinets Are Good Candidates for Paint

Solid boxes and doors: Solid wood, plywood and MDF cabinets paint very well.

A layout you like: Paint changes the look, not the layout. If you want to move the sink or add an island, you are into renovation territory.

Doors in good shape: Minor dents and scratches can be filled. Warped or delaminating doors cannot be fixed with paint.

When Replacement Makes More Sense

If cabinet boxes are water-damaged, especially under the sink, if particleboard is swelling, or if thermofoil doors are peeling, painting will not solve the underlying problem. The same goes if you want to change the layout or cabinet sizes.

What a Proper Cabinet Painting Process Looks Like

Cabinet painting fails when it is treated like wall painting. A durable job includes:

Removal and labelling: Doors and drawer fronts come off and are labelled so they go back exactly where they came from.

Degreasing: Kitchen cabinets carry years of cooking grease. Paint will not bond to it.

Sanding: Scuff-sanding gives the primer something to grip.

Bonding primer: A primer made for slick or previously finished surfaces.

Cabinet-grade enamel: Hard-curing finishes designed for cabinets, ideally sprayed on doors for a smooth result.

Cure time: Enamel feels dry in hours but takes longer to fully harden. Gentle use for the first couple of weeks pays off.

Oak Grain

Oak has an open grain that will show through paint. Some people like the texture; others want a smooth, modern look. A grain filler before priming gives a smoother finish.

The Bottom Line

If your cabinets are sound and the layout works, painting is usually the best value in a kitchen update. A painter should look at your cabinets in person and tell you honestly whether they are good candidates.

Planning a Painting Project?

Get a free, detailed written estimate from Hamilton Painting Company.

Now Booking Interior & Exterior Projects

Ready for a Fresh Coat?

Get a free, no-obligation painting estimate from Hamilton Painting Company. Tell us about your project and we will get back to you quickly.

No ObligationWritten QuotesThorough Prep3-Year Warranty
(647) 797-9471